KycoReview
Risk Alerts

SEC Risk Alert Finds Gaps in Lost Securityholder Rule Compliance

Aug 28, 20263 min read
In short: An Aug. 28, 2026 SEC risk alert found transfer agents and brokers missing searches, deadlines and written procedures under the lost securityholder rule.

A risk alert is a staff publication from the SEC’s Division of Examinations that shares deficiencies seen in exams, and the alert issued on August 28, 2026 focused on a technical but consequential obligation: finding investors whose mail comes back and paying people who never cash their checks.

What happened

The Division released observations on compliance with Exchange Act Rule 17Ad-17, the lost securityholder and unresponsive payee rule. The rule applies to transfer agents, to broker-dealers that hold customer securities accounts, and to paying agents. Examiners reviewed compliance across multiple firms and reported widespread problems.

The deficiencies fell into several groups.

Written procedures. Many firms had no written procedures at all, even though they were running searches. Where procedures existed, they often fell short of the rule or skipped basic steps such as how to identify and code a lost securityholder.

Database searches. Searches did not cover all lost securityholders and unresponsive payees. Some records were miscoded, including people wrongly designated as deceased. Some firms searched using a combination of taxpayer ID and name without a basis for doing so.

Timing. First searches were run more than 12 months after a holder became lost. Second searches came less than six months after the first. Notices to unresponsive payees went out after the seven-month deadline.

Recordkeeping. Firms did not document search dates or notice mailings.

Electronic communications. Procedures did not account for undeliverable emails when deciding whether a holder had become lost.

How it works

The rule requires covered firms to exercise reasonable care to find the correct address of a lost securityholder. In practice that means two database searches: the first between three and 12 months after the holder becomes lost, and a second between six and 12 months after the first. Searches should be run by taxpayer identification number, or by name if a TIN search is unlikely to succeed.

For unresponsive payees, meaning people who have not negotiated a check, paying agents must send a written notice within seven months of sending the uncashed check. Firms must also keep written procedures describing how they comply.

Why it matters: lost holders and uncashed checks often end up escheated to states as unclaimed property. Searches and notices give investors a chance to reclaim assets before that happens.

The findings also show how routine operations can create regulatory exposure. Miscoding a living holder as deceased, for example, can stop searches entirely, while a missed seven-month notice deadline can leave an uncashed payment unaddressed until it is turned over to a state.

Key terms

  • Lost securityholder: A holder to whom correspondence has been returned as undeliverable, under the rule’s definition.
  • Unresponsive payee: A person who has not negotiated a check sent by a paying agent.
  • Transfer agent: A firm that keeps records of who owns a company’s securities.
  • Paying agent: A firm that distributes interest, dividends or other payments to holders.
  • Escheatment: The transfer of unclaimed property to a state.

FAQ

Who should read this risk alert?

Transfer agents, broker-dealers with customer securities accounts and paying agents. The findings are specific enough to use as a self-assessment checklist.

Is email now part of the analysis?

The alert faulted procedures that ignored undeliverable emails when identifying lost holders, so electronic bounces should be considered alongside returned mail.

Can this lead to compliance enforcement?

Risk alerts are not enforcement actions, but examiners issue deficiency letters, and unremediated findings can be referred to the Division of Enforcement.

What should firms do now?

Write or update procedures, verify search timing and methodology, audit coding, and keep evidence of each search and notice.

Prepared with AI assistance from public sources and reviewed under our editorial policy. Not investment advice.

Related