KycoReview
SEC

SEC Compliance Enforcement: Fund Scheme Targeting Florida Police

Sep 23, 20263 min read
In short: The SEC charged CMI Capital LLC and founder Michael D. Williams over an alleged $860,000 fund scheme aimed at South Florida police. Details and red flags.

Affinity fraud is an investment scheme that exploits the trust within an identifiable group, such as a profession or community, and on September 23, 2026, the SEC filed a compliance enforcement action alleging one that targeted current and retired law enforcement officers in South Florida. The allegations have not been proven, and the defendants have agreed to settle without admitting the allegations.

What happened

The SEC charged CMI Capital LLC, which also does business as Check Mate Investments, and its founder and manager, Michael D. Williams of Port St. Lucie, Florida. The Commission alleges a fraudulent investment scheme that raised approximately $860,000 from at least 18 investors, many of them current or retired law enforcement officers in South Florida.

According to the complaint, filed in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Florida, Williams made numerous false and misleading statements from at least October 2023 through August 2024 to persuade clients to invest in two funds he controlled. Many investors allegedly trusted him because he worked for a third-party police and firefighter pension plan administrator. Investors were allegedly told that one of the funds had a portfolio value of more than $5 million and returns exceeding 140 percent.

The SEC alleges that the defendants sent investors cropped screenshots of graphics showing exorbitant trading profits. It also alleges that Williams misappropriated about $384,000 of investor and client money for personal expenses, including credit card balances, a sports car and vacations. The complaint says he began repaying certain investors in August 2024 and has repaid more than $375,000 to some of them. Stephanie N. Moot, Director of the SEC’s Miami Regional Office, urged investors to use caution when entrusting funds to others and to be wary of anyone promising high returns with little or no risk.

The charges and proposed settlement

The complaint charges Williams and CMI Capital with violating antifraud and registration provisions of the Securities Act of 1933 and antifraud provisions of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 and the Investment Advisers Act of 1940.

The defendants agreed to a bifurcated settlement, subject to court approval. Under the proposed judgments they would be permanently enjoined from violating the charged provisions, and Williams would also be enjoined from participating in the issuance, purchase, offer or sale of any security, apart from certain transactions in his own accounts. The court would later set disgorgement with prejudgment interest against Williams and civil penalties against both defendants. Williams also agreed to a forthcoming associational bar.

How the scheme works, as alleged

The pattern the SEC describes is familiar to compliance and KYC teams. A person with a credible role in a community, here employment with a pension plan administrator serving police and firefighters, presents himself as a source of investment opportunities. Verification of performance depends on documents that the manager controls, such as screenshots. Reported returns are far above what a diversified portfolio would produce, and some investor money is used for personal spending. Partial repayments to certain investors can create an impression of solvency while the underlying statements remain false.

The SEC charged registration violations alongside the antifraud counts, so the way the funds were offered is part of the case alongside what investors were told. The release does not detail which registration provisions apply to which defendant.

Red flags and controls

Several features of the allegations correspond to standard diligence points for firms that custody, refer or administer assets involving small private funds:

  • Performance evidence that comes only from the manager and not from an independent custodian or administrator.
  • Claimed returns well above market norms with little disclosed risk.
  • Reliance on a personal relationship or professional affiliation in place of documented credentials.
  • Investor money used for personal expenses.

Firms that onboard fund managers or accept their client referrals should confirm custody arrangements, obtain account statements directly from the custodian and match registration status against the activities described.

Key terms

  • Affinity fraud: fraud that targets members of a group who share a common trait or affiliation.
  • Bifurcated settlement: a settlement that resolves liability and injunctive relief now and leaves monetary relief to be determined by the court.
  • Disgorgement: repayment of ill-gotten gains, often with prejudgment interest.
  • Associational bar: a prohibition on associating with certain regulated firms.

FAQ

Has a court found the defendants liable? Not yet. The settlement is subject to court approval, and the defendants consented without admitting the allegations.

How much money is involved? The SEC alleges about $860,000 was raised from at least 18 investors, with about $384,000 misappropriated.

Were investors repaid? The complaint says Williams repaid more than $375,000 to certain investors beginning in August 2024.

Prepared with AI assistance from public sources and reviewed under our editorial policy. Not investment advice.

Related