FINRA Best Execution Guidance: Regulatory Notice 26-15 Explained
FINRA best execution guidance is the body of interpretations under FINRA Rule 5310 that tells broker-dealers how to show they used reasonable diligence to get customers the most favorable terms available, and on July 24, 2026, FINRA published Regulatory Notice 26-15 asking the industry how that guidance should be updated.
What happened
FINRA issued the notice as part of its FINRA Forward rule modernization initiative. It requests comment on all aspects of Rule 5310 and the related guidance, with particular attention to the effect of the SEC’s proposal to rescind the trade-through rule, Rule 611 of Regulation NMS, and a related quote-locking provision, Rule 610(e). Comments are due by September 25, 2026. They may be submitted online through FINRA’s comment form, by email or by mail to the Office of the Corporate Secretary in Washington, and FINRA asks commenters to use only one method. All comments will be posted publicly.
FINRA states a preliminary view: the text of Rule 5310 and its supplementary material remain appropriately calibrated, and the principles-based approach continues to work. The guidance written around it, however, may need updating given changes in market structure and the SEC’s proposed changes to Regulation NMS. The notice asks commenters to provide data or other factual support wherever possible.
How best execution works today
Rule 5310 requires a member, in any transaction for or with a customer, to use reasonable diligence to ascertain the best market for the security and to buy or sell in that market so that the resulting price to the customer is as favorable as possible under prevailing market conditions. Whether a firm met that standard depends on the facts. The rule and FINRA’s guidance list the character of the market, the size and type of the transaction, the number of markets checked, the accessibility of the quotation and the terms of the order as factors.
FINRA guidance also lists seven considerations for reviewing execution quality: the price obtained, the chance of price improvement elsewhere, the likelihood of execution, speed, size, transaction costs and customer needs. Firms that do not review order by order must conduct a regular and rigorous review by security and order type at least quarterly, and they must compare their execution quality with what competing markets offer, not just the venues they already use. Orders a firm internalizes are generally subject to order-by-order analysis, and a firm cannot hand its best execution duty to another broker-dealer by routing all of its flow there without an independent review.
The trade-through rule operates alongside this. Rule 611 has since 2005 barred trading centers from executing at prices inferior to protected quotations, which are limited to automated, round lot best bids and offers displayed on national securities exchanges. FINRA notes that compliance with Rule 611 does not equal best execution, and that the NBBO has become a benchmark firms use to evaluate routing and internalization. Firms have also built routing and connectivity around Rule 611, and some may be required to connect to venues showing protected quotes whatever their own view of execution quality there.
The questions FINRA is asking
The notice organizes its questions into nine topics. The first is best execution after Rules 611 and 610(e). It asks how guidance should treat decisions to connect, not connect or disconnect from venues once protected quotations disappear, and which factors firms should apply, such as liquidity thresholds, access fees, data costs, order types and latency. It asks how firms handle odd lots, fractional shares and over-the-counter equities, which already trade without a trade-through rule, and whether those practices could carry over to round lots. It asks whether the NBBO will remain the benchmark for price improvement or whether alternatives such as time-weighted or volume-weighted average prices are more appropriate, including for overnight trading when the securities information processors are not operating.
It also asks when it would be consistent with best execution not to access displayed liquidity, or to access displayed liquidity at an inferior price; whether FINRA should set standards for price improvement, address payment for order flow and internalization, or clarify “prevailing market conditions”; and whether to create safe harbors. It asks how FINRA should supervise best execution without a trade-through rule and what issues arise if self-regulatory organizations rescind their locked and crossed quote rules. FINRA Rule 6240 currently implements Rule 610(e).
The second topic is access fees and transaction costs. FINRA points to the SEC’s indication that it plans to review the access fee caps under Rule 610(c) by the end of the year, and asks whether guidance should say how venue fees and rebates enter a firm’s best execution analysis.
The remaining topics are best execution review standards, institutional orders, introducing and receiving firm obligations, extended trading hours, held and not held orders, listed options and emerging technologies.
Key terms
- Best execution: the broker-dealer duty to seek the most favorable terms reasonably available for a customer order.
- Trade-through: an execution at a price inferior to the best displayed price on another market.
- NBBO: the national best bid and offer, published by the securities information processors.
- Internalization: a firm executing a customer order from its own inventory.
- Access fee: the charge a venue levies for taking its displayed liquidity.
FAQ
Does the notice change any rule? No. It is a request for comment. FINRA says it believes Rule 5310 itself is appropriately calibrated and is exploring updates to interpretive guidance.
Is the trade-through rule already repealed? No. The SEC has proposed to rescind it. The notice assumes rescission for purposes of its questions.
Who should respond? Member firms with order routing, internalization or wholesale execution businesses, as well as trading venues and investor advocates, are the natural commenters. Compliance staff at firms should map current routing and review procedures to the topics listed so they can identify what would need to change.
Prepared with AI assistance from public sources and reviewed under our editorial policy. Not investment advice.

